成人X站

DAVE ROSS

Want to shoot down a carbon fee? Just call it a tax

Oct 22, 2019, 4:28 PM

Initiative 732, I-732, carbon tax, carbon fee, climate change, cap-and-invest, climate...

The Tesoro Corp. refinery, in Anacortes, Wash. Gas flares like this are part of normal plant operations. (AP)

(AP)

If you look at it one way, a carbon fee makes sense. After all, the average American pays a fee to have their garbage collected, taken away, and handled properly. Why not have large corporations pay a fee for their garbage which is released into the environment every American lives in.

Amazon aims to be carbon zero by 2040

Right now, companies dispose of waste for free. Under a system of fines for carbon, the free market kicks in and people vote with their dollars. So why not a carbon fee?

鈥淟ook at Washington鈥檚 carbon fee last year,鈥 Kate Yoder told 成人X站 Radio’s Dave Ross. 鈥淪upporters called it a fee on pollution, but the industry rebranded it as a tax, and it failed.鈥

Yoder recently explained this distinction in an, Voters like taxing carbon as long as you don鈥檛 say “carbon tax.”

鈥淧eople have been resistant to that term (a tax) since before our country even started,鈥 she added.

She points to a which discovered that more Americans like the idea of a carbon tax, as long as it isn鈥檛 called a 鈥渃arbon tax.鈥 She further notes that polls generally show that people favor climate causes such as clean air and water. And such causes equate to fines on companies that pollute the air and water.

鈥淎ccording to the study, 35% of people supported a carbon tax, but more than half supported the same thing when it was called 鈥榓 fine on corporations that pollute鈥 instead,” Yoder said. “But the one issue is that the fossil fuel industry knows the same information.鈥

Carbon fee initiatives in Washington

All of this can depend on who the voter trusts and also how the fee is set up. In Washington, that can be difficult to determine.

The last proposal for a carbon fee that Washington voters weighed in on in 2018 — I-1631 — set up a board composed of a series of environmental groups that would decide what to do with the money. That lack of clarity and specifics rubbed some people the wrong way. I-1631 aimed to establish a $15 per metric ton of carbon starting in 2020, increasing by $2 every year after that.

Bill Gates ultimately came out in support of I-1631, basically arguing that something needed to be done and that it would support renewable energies. Other advocates, however, argued that I-1631 was the wrong way to go. Meteorologist Cliff Mass opposed 1631, but favored a previous carbon fee that voters also rejected — I-732. That initiative copied the carbon fee from Canada and made it revenue neutral, so it wouldn’t harm the consumer while putting pressure on polluters. I-732 would eventually have placed a $100 per metric ton fee on carbon polluters.

Cliff Mass: How to make a carbon tax work in Washington

鈥(Taxpayers) just want the system to be fair,鈥澛 Yoder said. 鈥淭hat means that big corporations and the rich aren鈥檛 getting a free pass. Generally, the proposals I鈥檝e seen for carbon taxes are different from property taxes in that the tax money isn鈥檛 going back to the government, it鈥檚 usually being sent back to the American people in the form of a check to offset the cost of gas prices going up, that sort of thing. Or it鈥檚 being spent directly in the communities that are harmed by climate change and investing in renewable energy.鈥

Whatever the debate ends up being, Yoder argues that waiting for the perfect proposal for a carbon pollution fee is pointless 鈥 something needs to be done, soon, after so many years of inaction.

鈥淓ven though it is generally, politically unpopular because it would make some of the things we like more expensive,鈥 Yoder said. 鈥淎nother thing we like is having a habitable planet. And it might be time to get our priorities straight in that regard.鈥

Dave's Commentary

Dave Ross on 成人X站 Newsradio 97.3 FM
  • to 成人X站 Newsradio weekdays at 5am for Dave Ross on Seattle's Morning News.

Dave Ross

Image: From left, Chris Sullivan, Dave Ross and Colleen O'Brien stand together in the 成人X站 Newsradi...

MyNorthwest Staff

Dave and Colleen’s final ‘SMN:’ 成人X站 colleagues, politicians say their goodbyes

"Seattle's Morning News" on 成人X站 Newsradio will soon have a new sound. On Thursday, Dave Ross and Colleen O'Brien will host their last show together after a decade of co-hosting.

7 months ago

Classical literature on bookshelves. (Photo by Richard Baker / In Pictures via Getty Images)...

Dave Ross

Dave Ross as you’ve never heard him before: ‘I like fat books and I can’t deny’

"This song, inspired by one of my first interviews when I started my talk show, which was Sir Mix-A-Lot," Dave Ross said.

7 months ago

national debt...

Dave Ross

‘Don’t cut a cent:’ Dave Ross on why the national debt never gets under control

The national debt now exceeds $36 trillion, and every president says it has to be under control. And yet, it never is.

7 months ago

voters hormone...

Dave Ross

Ross: Voters weren鈥檛 just voting for change, they were voting for a hormone

The more I read the post-election analysis, the more I鈥檓 convinced voters weren鈥檛 just voting for a change 鈥 they were voting for a hormone.

8 months ago

ross o'brien - Seattle's Morning News...

Frank Sumrall

Dave Ross, Colleen O’Brien departing after co-hosting ‘Seattle’s Morning News’ for a decade

Dave Ross and Colleen O'Brien, the co-hosts of "Seattle's Morning News" on 成人X站 Newsradio are both leaving the show.

8 months ago

election day...

Dave Ross

Dave Ross: Election Day and Decision Day are two separate things

Tomorrow is Election Day 鈥 that鈥檚 what the calendar says. But there are two problems with the term "Election Day."

8 months ago

Want to shoot down a carbon fee? Just call it a tax