³ÉÈËXÕ¾

DAVE ROSS

Former WA Attorney General on whether media outlets will have to hand over footage to SPD

Aug 29, 2020, 8:04 AM

Seattle protest media footage, seattle police officers...

Police officers look on at protesters in Seattle. (AP Photo/Elaine Thompson, File)

(AP Photo/Elaine Thompson, File)

A handful of local media outlets to turn over raw video footage and still photos taken during a late-May protest to the Seattle Police Department. With the outlets now asking the state Supreme Court to intervene, former Washington Attorney General Rob McKenna weighed in on how the court might rule in the days ahead.

Judge grants pause on SPD subpoena for media footage of protest

“If a judge is persuaded that the information is both highly material and relevant and isn’t available from another source … I think they’re going to order the news outlets to hand it over,” McKenna told Dave Ross on Seattle’s Morning News.

This originally began with a subpoena from SPD to identify suspects in an arson and a firearm theft, where King County Superior Court Judge Nelson Lee gave the Seattle Times, KING 5, ³ÉÈËXÕ¾ 7, KOMO, and Q13 until Aug. 21 to hand over their footage.

A recent filing from the media outlets asks the state Supreme Court to put a pause on Judge Lee’s ruling until the case is resolved in a lower appeals court.

The outlets, McKenna describes, are looking for protection afforded by a law he actually helped craft when he was still the state’s Attorney General, called the Washington Shield Law.

“It’s a law that first of all, is designed to protect confidential sources that the media relies on in their reporting,” McKenna described. “But secondly, it’s designed to protect media outlets from fishing expeditions by law enforcement agencies that want them to turn over their notes, their outtakes, photographs, video clips, you name it.”

There are also exceptions built into the law, that say “a court may compel disclosure of the news or information if it finds that the information is needed in a criminal investigation … where there’s no other source for that information.”

Councilmember: SPD compelling media to hand over footage is ‘abhorrent’

“At the same time, whether it’s a criminal investigation or civil action, the news or information that the police or another agency are trying to obtain has to be highly material and relevant here,” McKenna said. “The TV stations and the Seattle Times are arguing that the police don’t need this footage and don’t need these photographs.”

Police do have security camera footage from that protest, but have said that it isn’t definitive enough to identify potential suspects.

“Those grainy black and white security camera videos often aren’t very useful,” McKenna pointed out.

Ultimately, it will be up to SPD to prove in court that the footage and photos are necessary resources to its investigation.

“We recognize sometimes there are imperatives in a criminal proceeding or civil action that require the information to be turned over, and in those cases, the party seeking the disclosure, like the police department, has to meet that standard — it’s not automatic.”

Listen to Seattle’s Morning News weekday mornings from 5 – 9 a.m. on ³ÉÈËXÕ¾ Radio, 97.3 FM. Subscribe to the podcast here.

Dave's Commentary

Dave Ross on ³ÉÈËXÕ¾ Newsradio 97.3 FM
  • to ³ÉÈËXÕ¾ Newsradio weekdays at 5am for Dave Ross on Seattle's Morning News.

Dave Ross

Image: From left, Chris Sullivan, Dave Ross and Colleen O'Brien stand together in the ³ÉÈËXÕ¾ Newsradi...

MyNorthwest Staff

Dave and Colleen’s final ‘SMN:’ ³ÉÈËXÕ¾ colleagues, politicians say their goodbyes

"Seattle's Morning News" on ³ÉÈËXÕ¾ Newsradio will soon have a new sound. On Thursday, Dave Ross and Colleen O'Brien will host their last show together after a decade of co-hosting.

7 months ago

Classical literature on bookshelves. (Photo by Richard Baker / In Pictures via Getty Images)...

Dave Ross

Dave Ross as you’ve never heard him before: ‘I like fat books and I can’t deny’

"This song, inspired by one of my first interviews when I started my talk show, which was Sir Mix-A-Lot," Dave Ross said.

7 months ago

national debt...

Dave Ross

‘Don’t cut a cent:’ Dave Ross on why the national debt never gets under control

The national debt now exceeds $36 trillion, and every president says it has to be under control. And yet, it never is.

7 months ago

voters hormone...

Dave Ross

Ross: Voters weren’t just voting for change, they were voting for a hormone

The more I read the post-election analysis, the more I’m convinced voters weren’t just voting for a change – they were voting for a hormone.

8 months ago

ross o'brien - Seattle's Morning News...

Frank Sumrall

Dave Ross, Colleen O’Brien departing after co-hosting ‘Seattle’s Morning News’ for a decade

Dave Ross and Colleen O'Brien, the co-hosts of "Seattle's Morning News" on ³ÉÈËXÕ¾ Newsradio are both leaving the show.

8 months ago

election day...

Dave Ross

Dave Ross: Election Day and Decision Day are two separate things

Tomorrow is Election Day – that’s what the calendar says. But there are two problems with the term "Election Day."

8 months ago

Former WA Attorney General on whether media outlets will have to hand over footage to SPD