Abrego Garcia’s lawyers ask judge to fine Trump administration for contempt
Jun 12, 2025, 10:04 AM
FILE - This undated photo provided by Murray Osorio PLLC shows Kilmar Abrego Garcia. (Murray Osorio PLLC via AP)
Credit: ASSOCIATED PRESS
(Murray Osorio PLLC via AP)
Lawyers for Kilmar Abrego Garcia have asked a federal judge in Maryland to impose fines against the Trump administration for contempt, arguing that it flagrantly ignored court ordersfor several weeks to return him to the U.S. from El Salvador.
Abrego Garcia’s attorneys said the administration claimed to be powerless to retrieve him, even while it secretly built a human smuggling case against him. The U.S. brought Abrego Garcia to a federal court in Nashville, Tennessee last week to face those charges.
鈥淭he Government鈥檚 defiance has not been subtle,鈥� the attorneys said in a filing late Wednesday. 鈥淚t has been vocal and sustained and flagrant.鈥�
The attorneys also are asking U.S. District Court Judge Paula Xinis to compel the release of documents the federal government withheld by claiming they contain protected state secrets. Or as an alternative, the lawyers suggested a special master to investigate the government’s 鈥渨illful noncompliance鈥� of court orders.
鈥淲hat the Government improperly seeks to hide must be exposed for all to see,鈥� Abrego Garcia鈥檚 attorneys wrote.
Their request came a day after the Trump administration said it will ask Xinis to dismiss the case, with U.S. attorneys describing recent accusations by Abrego Garcia’s attorneys as baseless, desperate and disappointing.
鈥淏ut the proof is in the pudding 鈥� Defendants have returned Abrego Garcia to the United States just as they were ordered to do,鈥� they wrote.
Legal experts said last month that the Abrego Garcia case may be headed for contempt. And the request by his attorneys adds to the ongoing friction between the White House and the courts during President Donald Trump’s second term.
Courts can hold parties to civil litigation or criminal cases in contempt for disobeying their orders. The penalty can take the form of fines or other civil punishments, or even prosecution and jail time, if pursued criminally. But contempt processes are slow and deliberative, and, when the government鈥檚 involved, there鈥檚 usually a resolution before penalties kick in.
The U.S. mistakenly deported Abrego Garcia to an El Salvador prison in March. The expulsion violated a U.S. immigration judge’s order in 2019 that shielded him from deportation to his native country because he likely faced gang persecution there.
Abrego Garcia’s American wife sued, prompting Xinis to order his return on April 4. The Supreme Court ruled April 10 that the administration must work to bring him back.
Arguments ensued over the next several weeks about whether the Trump administration was following those orders or not. Trump also said publicly that he could return Abrego Garcia to the U.S. with a call to El Salvador President Nayib Bukele.
Xinis ordered U.S. attorneys to submit documents and testimony to show what the government had done to follow her orders. The Trump administration claimed that much of that information is protected under the state secrets privilege. The judge has not ruled on that matter.
