NATIONAL NEWS

Minnesota considers blocking ‘nudify’ apps that use AI to make explicit images without consent

Mar 4, 2025, 11:35 AM

Minnesota Democratic State Senator Erin Maye Quade, center, discusses her bill to crack down on "nu...

Minnesota Democratic State Senator Erin Maye Quade, center, discusses her bill to crack down on "nudification" apps during a news conference at the Minnesota State Capitolo in St. Paul on Monday, Feb. 24, 2025. She was joined by Megan Hurley, left, and Molly Kelly, right, who both told reporters how they were victims of the technology. (AP Photo/Steve Karnowski)
Credit: ASSOCIATED PRESS

(AP Photo/Steve Karnowski)

ST. PAUL, Minn. (AP) — Molly Kelly was stunned to discover in June that someone she knew had used widely available “nudification” technology to create highly realistic and sexually explicit videos and images of her, using family photos that were posted on social media.

“My initial shock turned to horror when I learned that the same person targeted about 80, 85 other women, most of whom live in Minnesota, some of whom I know personally, and all of them had connections in some way to the offender,” Kelly said.

Backed by her testimony, Minnesota is considering a new strategy for cracking down on deepfake pornography. A bill that has bipartisan support would target companies that run websites and apps allowing people to upload a photo that then would be transformed into explicit images or videos.

States across the country and Congress are considering strategies for regulating artificial intelligence. Most have banned the dissemination of sexually explicit deepfakes or revenge porn whether they were produced with AI or not. The idea behind the Minnesota legislation is to prevent the material from ever being created — before it spreads online.

Experts on AI law caution the proposal might be unconstitutional on free speech grounds.

Why advocates say the bill is needed

The lead author, Democratic Sen. Erin Maye Quade, said additional restrictions are necessary because AI technology has advanced so rapidly. Her bill would require the operators of “nudification” sites and apps to turn them off to people in Minnesota or face civil penalties up to $500,000 “for each unlawful access, download, or use.” Developers would need to figure out how to exclude Minnesota users.

It’s not just the dissemination that’s harmful to victims, she said. It’s the fact that these images exist at all.

Kelly told reporters last month that anyone can quickly create “hyper-realistic nude images or pornographic video” in minutes.

Most law enforcement attention so far has been focused on distribution and possession.

Congress, states and cities are also trying other tactics

San Francisco in August filed a first-of-its-kind lawsuit against several widely visited “nudification” websites, alleging they broke state laws against fraudulent business practices, nonconsensual pornography and the sexual abuse of children. That case remains pending.

The U.S. Senate last month unanimously approved a bill by Democrat Amy Klobuchar, of Minnesota, and Republican Ted Cruz, of Texas, to make it a federal crime to publish nonconsensual sexual imagery, including AI-generated deepfakes. Social media platforms would be required to remove them within 48 hours of notice from a victim. Melania Trump on Monday used her first solo appearance since becoming first lady again to urge passage by the Republican-controlled House, where it’s pending.

The Kansas House last month approved a bill that expands the definition of illegal sexual exploitation of a child to include possession of images generated with AI if they’re “indistinguishable from a real child, morphed from a real child’s image or generated without any actual child involvement.”

A bill introduced in the Florida Legislature creates a new felony for people who use technology such as AI to generate nude images and criminalizes possession of child sexual abuse images generated with it. Broadly similar bills have also been introduced in Illinois, Montana, New Jersey, New York, North Dakota, Oregon, Rhode Island, South Carolina and Texas, according to an

Maye Quade said she’ll be sharing her proposal with legislators in other states because few are aware the technology is so readily accessible.

“If we can’t get Congress to act, then we can maybe get as many states as possible to take action,” Maye Quade said.

Victims tell their stories

Sandi Johnson, senior legislative policy counsel for the victim’s rights group RAINN — the Rape, Abuse and Incest National Network — said the Minnesota bill would hold websites accountable.

“Once the images are created, they can be posted anonymously, or rapidly widely disseminated, and become nearly impossible to remove,” she testified recently.

Megan Hurley also was horrified to learn someone had generated explicit images and video of her using a “nudification” site. She said she feels especially humiliated because she’s a massage therapist, a profession that’s already sexualized in some minds.

“It is far too easy for one person to use their phone or computer and create convincing, synthetic, intimate imagery of you, your family, and friends, your children, your grandchildren,” Hurley said. “I do not understand why this technology exists and I find it abhorrent there are companies out there making money in this manner.”

AI experts urge caution

However, two AI law experts — Wayne Unger of the Quinnipiac University School of Law and Riana Pfefferkorn of Stanford University’s Institute of Human-Centered Artificial Intelligence — said the Minnesota bill is too broadly constructed to survive a court challenge.

Limiting the scope only to images of real children might help it withstand a First Amendment challenge since those are generally not protected, Pfefferkorn said. But she said it would still potentially conflict with a federal law that says you can’t sue websites for content that users generate.

“If Minnesota wants to go down this direction, they’ll need to add a lot more clarity to the bill,” Unger said. “And they’ll have to narrow what they mean by nudify and nudification.”

But Maye Quade said she thinks her legislation is on solid constitutional ground because it’s regulating conduct, not speech.

“This cannot continue,” she said. “These tech companies cannot keep unleashing this technology into the world with no consequences. It is harmful by its very nature.”

___

Associated Press reporters Matt O’Brien, John Hanna and Kate Payne contributed to this story from Providence, Rhode Island; Wichita, Kansas; and Tallahassee, Florida, respectively.

National News

Endurance swimmer Lewis Pugh gestures to where he will begin his swim around Martha's Vineyard isla...

Associated Press

AP PHOTOS: Athlete to attempt first-ever swim around Martha’s Vineyard ahead of ‘Jaws’ anniversary

MARTHA’S VINEYARD, Mass. (AP) — An athlete will aim to be the first person to swim around Martha’s Vineyard to educate the public on sharks. Lewis Pugh will attempt the swim in 47-degree (8-degree Celsius) water during the start of white shark migration season. The swim is planned to correspond with the 50th anniversary of […]

13 minutes ago

FILE - The Harvard University logo is displayed on a building at the school, Tuesday, April 15, 202...

Associated Press

Americans are divided over DEI programs on college campuses, an AP-NORC poll finds

WASHINGTON (AP) — As President Donald Trump seeks to end diversity, equity and inclusion practices on college campuses, a new poll suggests that while the concept of DEI is divisive, some of the initiatives being affected by his administration’s guidance are less controversial. The poll, conducted earlier this month by The Associated Press-NORC Center for […]

20 minutes ago

FILE - The Supreme Court is seen on Capitol Hill in Washington, Dec. 17, 2024. (AP Photo/J. Scott A...

Associated Press

In their words: What judges have said about birthright citizenship and nationwide injunctions

WASHINGTON (AP) — Federal courts have uniformly blocked President Donald Trump’s order seeking to end birthright citizenship for children born in the United States to someone in the country illegally. The Supreme Court is hearing arguments Thursday in appeals of three of those orders that prevented the Trump administration’s citizenship restrictions from taking effect anywhere […]

52 minutes ago

Dumbbells are displayed at a Walmart, Wednesday, April 16, 2025, in Groton, Conn. (AP Photo/Julia D...

Associated Press

Walmart says it will raise prices due to tariff costs after posting solid first quarter sales

NEW YORK (AP) — Walmart’s first quarter profit slipped and it said it must raise prices due to higher costs from tariffs implemented by President Donald Trump. The nation’s largest retailers posted strong quarterly sales Thursday and said it expects sales growth of 3.5% to 4.5% in the second quarter. Like many other U.S. companies, […]

59 minutes ago

FILE - White House executive chef Cris Comerford, holds dishes as she speaks during a media preview...

Associated Press

Former White House chef for 5 presidents says first families are ‘just regular people’ at home

WASHINGTON (AP) — Cristeta Comerford, a longtime White House executive chef who recently retired after nearly three decades of preparing meals for five presidents and their guests, says first families are “just regular people” when they’re at home in the private living areas of the executive mansion. “It’s not what you see on the news,” […]

2 hours ago

Palestinians evacuate after the Israeli army issued an evacuation warning for several schools and a...

Associated Press

54 people killed in overnight airstrikes on southern Gaza city, hospital says

KHAN YOUNIS, Gaza Strip (AP) — A hospital in southern Gaza says 54 people have been killed in overnight airstrikes on the city of Khan Younis. An Associated Press cameraman in Khan Younis counted 10 airstrikes on the city overnight into Thursday, and saw numerous bodies taken to the morgue in the city’s Nasser Hospital. […]

5 hours ago

Minnesota considers blocking ‘nudify’ apps that use AI to make explicit images without consent