âI was very surprisedâ: Local victims get back more than just stolen car
Feb 15, 2025, 5:00 AM

Some people who have had their cars stolen get more than just their cars back. (COURTESY łÉÈËXŐŸ-7)
(COURTESY łÉÈËXŐŸ-7)
If your car is stolen, you may just get it back with more than you bargained for.
More than 26,000 cars were stolen in Washington last year according to the Puget Sound Auto Theft Task Force, and if their owners are fortunate enough to get them back, theyâre often saddled with a time-consuming new problem: they need to clean up and clean out their vehicle.
It happened to Alaina Nieto. Her car was stolen for the second time in January. When she got it back, Nieto said police called and told her the car was at an impound lot.
âGarbage bags of clothes and toilet paper and just tools and random things,â she said. âWhat wasnât in the car? There was a ton.â
So what do you do?
âWe had called the non-emergency line and asked, âWhat do we do with this stuff?ââ she said. âAnd they just kind of said, âThatâs up to you.ââ
âWere you surprised?â łÉÈËXŐŸ 7 reporter Linzi Sheldon asked.
âI was very surprised,â Nieto said. âI felt like maybe more care should be put into getting other people reunited with their stuff.â
Nieto found a hand torch. An iPod Touch. Dozens of tools. And even Christmas ornaments.
A lot of people wouldâve just thrown it all out. But Nieto sorted through it and found a flute with a local public school sticker on it. She managed to track down the owner through social media.
And then a blue velvet bag caught her eye. Inside: a paw print and a small bag of cat fur.
She knew it was important. Weâll get back to that in a bit.
Getting a car back full of random items happens a lot more often than you might think.
łÉÈËXŐŸ 7 connected with Nieto through a Facebook page called PNW Stolen Cars. It has over 150,000 members and when łÉÈËXŐŸ 7 reporter Linzi Sheldon posted to ask about peopleâs experiences in situations like this, she received more than two hundred responses.
One man found a machete. He said the police told him he could keep it.
One woman said deputies told her a drill wasnât reported stolen, so it was hers.
And another woman found three extra laptops left in her car, even after she told officers they werenât hers.
âIf Iâm investigating that, that would more than likely tell me that those are stolen,â King County Sheriffâs Office Detective Mike Ramirez said of the laptops case. âSo I would seize them temporarily and try to see if I could find the owner by serial number.â
łÉÈËXŐŸ 7 met up with Detective Ramirez at Bankerâs impound lot in Renton. He works for Covington Police through their contract with the Sheriffâs Office.
So what exactly is the policy?
What are your rights and what steps should you take if you get your car back with strangersâ valuable stuff still inside?
âDo I call police and say, âHey, these things are not mine? You might have thought they were mine. Can you take them off my hands and reunite them with their owners?ââ Sheldon asked.
âIf you donât want it, we take it,â Ramirez said. âWe store it. And, you know, at some point, whatever happens to it, itâll stay in storage for years. And then we figure out what we do with it later on. We have our policies. Every department has a policy, what they do with property.â
Unfortunately, for items that arenât worth much, that are hard to trace back to an owner, or things like garbage and other messes, itâs up to the carâs owner or insurance company to clean out.
âThe residue of fentanyl stays, it lingers and it sticks to the surface,â Ramirez said.
And what if you find and turn on something like a cell phone that has GPS tracking?
âAll of a sudden somebody comes knocking at your door, [saying,] âHey, you have my phone!â âOh yeah, I found it in the car.â Technically, youâre in possession of stolen property, right?â Ramirez said.
He said in a case like this, thereâs an obvious paper trail, like a police report.
âYou have an explanation as to what happened,â he said.
Despite all the cleanup Nieto had to do, she wasnât going to throw out that blue velvet bag.
âSo there was a barcode,â she said. âAnd I called the animal hospital and I just said the pet name on it.â
Emma Loomis. Emma, the cat.
The vet connected her with Kristina Loomis, who told łÉÈËXŐŸ 7 that Emma was particularly special to her daughter, Sabrina.
âI immediately broke out in tears,â Loomis said. â[Sabrina] had requested to have her paw print to remember her by.â
When Sabrinaâs car was broken into, they thought they had lost this last piece of Emma forever.
âTo get this phone call out of the blue. It was amazing,â Loomis said. âShe didnât have to call us. She didnât have to track us down⊠but she went the extra mile to make sure that they got back to us.â
Nieto said she did it because she knows what it feels like to be a victim.
âIt messes with your sense of security,â she said. âIt makes you feel violated. And I just wanted to help anyone who I could.â
So what about other departmentsâ policies?
Seattle Police said they seize evidence, but sometimes officers donât know what belongs to the owner and what is stolen. If you find valuable items, you have to advocate for yourself and tell officers to come pick them up.
The Pierce County Sheriffâs Office said owners often tell them about found property and theyâll book it for safekeeping as they try to track down the owners.
Everett Police said they really try to talk to the carâs owner as soon as they find it abandoned. That way they know what items to take to try to return them.
In all three cases, departments said they look to seize evidence and anything that might be stolen but may need people to speak up if they find a valuable itemâespecially one with a serial numberâthat can be traced back to its owner.
©2025 Cox Media Group