成人X站

MYNORTHWEST NEWS

Are ‘sweeps’ of Seattle homeless camps unconstitutional?

Dec 11, 2017, 7:16 AM | Updated: 10:15 am

Aberdeen, homeless, homelessness, Seattle, homeless crisis, homeless population...

(File, Associated Press)

(File, Associated Press)

There are more than 11,000 homeless people in Seattle and King County, and the state of emergency surrounding the city鈥檚 homeless crisis was a focal point of this year鈥檚 mayoral race.

While Mayor Jenny Durkan, who assumed office after winning the election in November, is in favor of police 鈥渟weeps鈥 of homeless encampments, former candidate Nikkita Oliver believes such sweeps are inhumane. She joined Dave Ross and Colleen O鈥橞rien on 成人X站 Radio to talk about better solutions.

Lessons learned to fight the Seattle homeless crisis

The population of homeless people in the U.S. increased for the first time in seven years, according to a new federal report released last week. King County鈥檚 homeless population now ranks third in the nation 鈥 trailing only Los Angeles and New York City. Sweeps are one way the city has chosen to address the crisis of homelessness.

鈥淭here are very clear ways in which these sweeps violate the constitutional rights of those who are camping,鈥 Oliver said during an interview with Seattle鈥檚 Morning News. During these 鈥渟weeps,鈥 city officials give residents of an unauthorized encampment 72 hours鈥 notice before completely clearing out the campsite.

Oliver explained that the laws are overly broad and campers are sometimes not offered the full 72 hours required to evacuate if police or the city’s Navigation Team determine an 鈥渆mergency鈥 situation necessitates the sweep.

鈥淭here鈥檚 also supposed to be constitutional protections around the property of those who are living in the encampments, who are experiencing these sweeps. And oftentimes their property is destroyed, or not collected or retrieved in a way that they can find it later, and so the sweeps are not only unconstitutional but in a lot of ways they鈥檙e inhumane.鈥

Earlier this year, former Mayor Ed Murray announced the creation of the Navigation Team, which would aim to help people dislocated after camp sweeps find shelter solutions. However, Oliver argues these efforts are ultimately flawed because the city doesn鈥檛 have enough shelter space for its homeless population.

What goes on during a sweep?

Dave and Colleen were also joined by a camper who was forced to abandon a Ravenna-area site during a recent sweep.

鈥淭hey pretty much show up and take pictures one day, and then come out the next day and put up a piece of paper that tells you they鈥檙e going to come and take everything down,鈥 he said of the process. 鈥淭hey give you 72 hours, and then they show up 72 hours later and whatever you don鈥檛 have normally, they just kind of chew you off and destroy all your stuff.鈥

And by that, the camper literally means 鈥渄estroy鈥 鈥 officials will bulldoze a structure and clear out debris. But the process can be disruptive for small communities of homeless people who are otherwise self-sustaining.

鈥淥ur area was clean, and they just literally strewn everything that was in our structure 鈥 to where it just looked like a big trash pile,鈥 the camper said. 鈥淚t鈥檚 really inhumane, especially on Christmas, to take everything from someone who鈥檚 already had everything taken. Kind of kick them while they鈥檙e down. (I am) just wishing I could move back to that spot or be told where I can go.鈥

Still, others argue that the sweeps can constitute a violation of property rights (when officers seize, destroy, or search tents and belongings), which was the subject of a lawsuit earlier this year.

If sweeps aren鈥檛 the answer, what is?

For his part, the homeless camper believes the city could designate greenbelts and out-of-sight areas for camps, so that homeless people can find shelter there without fear of being evicted.

Oliver argues that the city can be smarter about the way it uses homeless funds.

鈥淚t鈥檚 going to be on our public officials to draw some hard lines in the sand and say that we value the health of our city,鈥 Oliver said, 鈥渁nd those who are living in encampments are a part of our city. So, we鈥檙e going to pour resources into human services and to developing shelters and affordable housing as a way of ensuring that everyone has a right to stay here and be healthy.鈥

鈥溾 We need to be finding humane ways of ensuring that people have safe places to be and sleep. The city has not effectively done that; its answer has been to sweep people around the city as opposed to providing multiple spaces where people can safely live … And people are self-managing — they鈥檙e managing their own spaces and ensuring that they鈥檙e safe. And they just want a safe space to live and be.鈥

MyNorthwest News

boeing china...

Associated Press

Justice Department reaches deal to allow Boeing to avoid prosecution over 737 Max crashes

The Justice Department's agreement allows Boeing to evade criminal charges related to the 737 Max crashes and misleading practices.

9 minutes ago

triple murder pioneer square arrests...

Frank Sumrall

Multiple suspects arrested for involvement in Pioneer Square triple murder

Homicide detectives with the Seattle Police Department (SPD), with the assistance of SWAT, arrested multiple suspects involved in the Pioneer Square triple murder that occurred last weekend.

1 hour ago

gas prices memorial day weekend wa...

Frank Sumrall

WA gas prices hold steady for Memorial Day weekend despite national prices falling

Gas prices have fallen to their lowest levels nationally this Memorial Day weekend since 2021, but Washington won't be able to enjoy the spoils.

2 hours ago

wsp trooper trial mexican national...

Frank Sumrall

Trial begins for Mexican national accused of killing WSP trooper while speeding under the influence

Opening statements for the trial for聽a man charged with killing a Washington State Patrol (WSP) trooper in March 2024 started today.

3 hours ago

everett boat search recovery...

Frank Sumrall

Boat sinks near Everett: 3 missing passengers presumed dead

The three people still missing after a shrimping boat sank near Everett Wednesday are presumed dead, the U.S. Coast Guard reported.

5 hours ago

11-time felon lacey burglary...

Frank Sumrall

11-time convicted felon found with guns, drugs, 50 car keys after Lacey burglary arrest

Lacey police officers discovered a variety of guns, car keys, cash, drugs, and other stolen items when searching the residence of an 11-time felon arrested for an alleged burglary.

6 hours ago

Are ‘sweeps’ of Seattle homeless camps unconstitutional?