Seafood company sues over terminated fish farming pen leases
Dec 16, 2022, 6:27 AM | Updated: 9:35 am
FILE - In this photo provided by the Washington State Department of Natural Resources, a crane and boats are anchored next to a collapsed "net pen" used by Cooke Aquaculture Pacific to farm Atlantic Salmon near Cypress Island in Washington state on Aug. 28, 2017. Washington has banned net-pen fish-farming in state waters, citing danger to struggling native salmon. Public Lands Commissioner Hilary Franz issued an executive order Friday banning such aquaculture. (David Bergvall/Washington State Department of Natural Resources via AP, File)
(David Bergvall/Washington State Department of Natural Resources via AP, File)
Cooke Aquaculture has filed an appeal against Washington state鈥檚 decision to end its leases for fish farming in state waters with net pens.
In court documents filed Wednesday, the New Brunswick, Canada-based seafood giant said that the decision was arbitrary, politically motivated, and contrary to science, .
In a statement, Cooke said it has a state Supreme Court ruling and legislative mandate on its side that supports the farming of native species. It also said that the 30-day deadline to harvest fish and to remove all farm equipment from two sites was unreasonable.
State Public Lands Commissioner Hilary Franz last month issued an executive order banning the aquaculture method, which involves raising fish in large floating pens anchored in the water, citing danger to struggling native salmon. The company had been told the previous week that their remaining leases wouldn鈥檛 be renewed.
The state Department of Natural Resources originally set a deadline of Dec. 14 for Cooke to remove its facilities from leased areas at Rich Passage near Bainbridge Island, and Hope Island in Skagit Bay, but the agency has since extended the deadline for removal of fish to Jan. 14 and removal of Cooke鈥檚 net pens to April 14.
In response to Wednesday鈥檚 filing, Franz said that Cooke had ample time to prepare operationally and financially for this decision.
鈥淢y denial of Cooke鈥檚 application is well supported by the law and their long track record of violating the terms of their leases,鈥� she said in a statement.
In 2017, tens of thousands of the company鈥檚 nonnative Atlantic salmon escaped after a pen break near the San Juan Islands. That sparked calls to end nonnative fish farming in Washington 鈥� with 20 western Washington treaty tribes at the forefront citing that the method undermines tribal treaty fishing rights.
Cooke pivoted to raise steelhead trout, but Department of Natural Resources officials determined that Cooke鈥檚 operations could pose risks to the state鈥檚 environment.
California, Oregon, and Alaska have outlawed net-pen aquaculture, and Canada is working on a plan to phase it out of British Columbia鈥檚 coastal waters by 2025. Supporters say fish farming is an environmentally safe way to feed the world鈥檚 growing population; critics argue that it can spread disease to native stocks and degrade the environment.
