MYNORTHWEST NEWS

WA jumps appeals court, asks state Supreme Court to take on legal battle over capital gains

Mar 30, 2022, 5:51 PM | Updated: Mar 31, 2022, 6:41 am

The interior of the Washington State Supreme Court (Wikimedia Commons)...

The interior of the Washington State Supreme Court (Wikimedia Commons)

(Wikimedia Commons)

There was never any doubt a recent Douglas County Superior Court Judge’s ruling that shot down the state’s new capital gains tax would be appealed – the only question was whether that would follow a traditional path or circumvent the state appeals court and go straight to the state Supreme Court.

Late last week that question was answered when the state Attorney General’s Office filed a  for direct review with the state Supreme Court.

The capital gains tax passed the legislature in 2021’s and the first lawsuit was filed before Governor Inslee even signed it.

In his March 4th ruling, Douglas County Judge Brian C. Huber rejected state claims that this was an excise tax, writing that the tax was “properly characterized as an income tax” pursuant to applicable Washington case law.

Washington state’s capital gains tax unconstitutional, rules Douglas County Court

“As a tax on the receipt of income, ESSB 5096 is also properly characterized as a tax on property pursuant to that same case law,” Huber wrote. “This Court concludes that ESSB 5096 violates the uniformity and limitation requirements of Article VII, sections 1 and 2 of the Washington State Constitution.”

Specifically, he pointed to the fact that ESSB 5096 imposes a 7% tax on capital gains over $250,000 but no tax on gains below that threshold as violation of the uniformity requirement, and said it violated the limitation requirement by imposing a 7% tax, higher than the 1% maximum tax rate on property of 1%.

State Attorney General Bob Ferguson said in a statement at the time that he disagreed with the judge’s ruling and that the state would appeal.

“There’s a great deal at stake in this case, including funding for early learning, child care programs, and school construction,” Ferguson said “Consequently, we will continue defending this law enacted by the peoples’ representatives in the Legislature.”

Ferguson noted all parties always expected the case to be decided by the state supreme court, but did not indicate whether he intended to pass over the traditional appeals court at the time.

The Freedom Foundation – the first to file a lawsuit against the tax — said in a this week it was not surprised Ferguson appealed straight to the state supreme court.

“The Freedom Foundation is not surprised Attorney General Ferguson appealed the judge’s decision directly to the state Supreme Court. Ferguson and the state are playing with our tax dollars to defend this illegal tax,” said Eric Stahlfeld, chief litigation counsel for the Freedom Foundation. “We were the first to file a lawsuit against this unconstitutional tax scheme, and we’ll continue to fight to defend Washington’s taxpayers.”

Many believe supporters of the capital gains tax have always intended to have the case go before the justices to create an opportunity for them to revisit a 1933 court ruling defining income as property that’s blocked efforts for a progressive income tax in Washington for 80 years.

MyNorthwest News

Washington state ferries wenatchee hybrid-electric ferry...

James Lynch

Washington State Ferries launches largest hybrid-electric ferry in North America

Discover how Washington State Ferries leads with the largest hybrid-electric ferry in North America, enhancing eco-friendly travel.

7 hours ago

opioid settlements Oxycodone pain pill...

Julia Dallas

Washington could receive $16 million as part of nationwide opioid settlements

Washington stands to gain $16 million from nationwide opioid settlements, aiding efforts to combat the ongoing crisis.

8 hours ago

King County Assessor John Wilson...

Julia Dallas

King County Assessor John Wilson suspends campaign for county executive

John Wilson, King County Assessor, halts his campaign for county executive amid allegations he violated a restraining order.

10 hours ago

Amazon Prime Day sales drop...

Jason Sutich

‘Still early in the event’: Amazon defends 41% Prime Day sales drop report

Amazon reports $7 billion in sales on day one, down 41% from last year, addressing concerns over declining momentum in Prime Day events.

12 hours ago

southbound sr 167 wsdot...

Nate Connors

Southbound SR 167 to remain open this weekend

The Washington Department of Transportation (WSDOT) has decided to keep Southbound SR 167 open this weekend amid a flurry of upcoming highway closures.

12 hours ago

lacey man arrested...

Frank Sumrall

Man arrested in Lacey for seventh time in last 14 months

The Lacey Police Department confirmed it arrested a man for the seventh time in the last 14 months.

12 hours ago

WA jumps appeals court, asks state Supreme Court to take on legal battle over capital gains