成人X站

SEATTLE NEWS ARCHIVES & FEATURES

‘Mamma Mia 2’ not nearly as terrible as the original

Jul 20, 2018, 10:07 AM

YouTube video

The first “Mamma Mia” movie was terrible. How could it not have been? It was based on the worst kind of musical – an entirely inorganic show, written in ridiculously twisted and contorted fashion so as to justify including completely unrelated songs. The actors, to their credit, were game but couldn’t really sing (Pierce Brosnan, anyone?), and the Abba songs were, what can I say, Abba songs. Like Kars-for-Kids commercials, they’re the very definition of earworms – impossible to get out of your head.

And now, a mere ten years later, we have a follow-up movie, “Mamma Mia: Here We Go Again.” (By the way, I take that phrase as a threat.)

And yes, it too is pretty terrible, but not nearly as terrible as the original.

For one thing, the prequel/sequel design of the show works well. Since we found out in “Mamma Mia” that Meryl Streep’s Donna had slept with three possible fathers of her daughter, Sophie, this time around we get to watch how young Donna met and matched with each of the three lovers.

Simultaneously, the film follows – in present time – Sophie’s efforts at opening a Hotel Bella Donna in her mom’s honor. (Spoiler alert: We find out in the first scene that Donna had died the year before.) The movie toggles back and forth between these two storylines, finding parallels along the way, one in particular that pays off nicely at the end.

The key to this design’s success is the casting of Lily James as Meryl Streep’s younger self. Best known for “Downton Abbey” and “Cinderella,” James not only brings a winning personality to the role, but she can actually sing.

But even James can’t save us from Abba duds like the film’s first big number “When I Kissed the Teacher,” especially when it’s so poorly choreographed.

This raises something of a dilemma for this sequel. Since the first film used up most of Abba’s hits, a lot of the 19 musical numbers here are relatively unknown. Whoever heard of “Kisses of Fire”? “Andante, Andante”? “My Love, My Life”? “The Day Before You Came?”

The film senses this and tries to make up for it with over-the top productions of the two big hits that didn’t make the first film’s storyline: “Waterloo” and “Fernando.” The latter is getting the most buzz because it’s done by Cher, who plays Donna’s prima donna mother.

I’ll grant you Cher’s voice fits the song nicely, but the staging is so clumsy, she looks even older than her 72 years.

The film also cheats a little by reprising the biggest hits from the first film – not just “Mamma Mia,” but also, of course, “Dancing Queen.”

Speaking of which, there are three nearly identical versions of “Dancing Queen,” despite the fact that one was recorded 42 years ago, another 10 years ago, and the other just this year.

I don’t mind a musical that takes old pop songs and revives them with a fresh new sound, or interpretation, or twist. Baz Luhrmann did that very thing in his excellent “Moulin Rouge.” But so many of the movie Mamma Mia songs are done so similarly to the original recordings as to seem redundant.

“But that’s the point!” I can hear Abba fans screaming at me right now. “We don’t want them to sound different! Ear worms forever!”

Starbucks close pick-up stores...

MyNorthwest Staff

Starbucks ending pick-up store format, up to 5 closures expected in Seattle

Starbucks plans to eliminate its mobile-order-only Pick Up store concept by 2026, a move that could impact up to five locations in the Seattle area.

2 minutes ago

WA wine sales decline...

Jason Sutich

WA wineries hit by 18% sales decline over past 3 years

Wine sales in Washington have recorded a substantial drop in recent years, down more than 18% since 2021, according to the Puget Sound Business Journal.

9 minutes ago

Buffalo herd US 12 closed...

Jason Sutich

Buffalo herd closes both directions of US 12 in Elma

A herd of buffalo blocked both directions of the highway on US 12 in Elma at 6:40 a.m. on Tuesday, the Washington State Department of Transportation confirmed.

2 hours ago

Lynnwood child shoots mother...

Jason Sutich

Weapons cache, homemade bombs found inside home of father in toddler shooting incident

The father of a 4-year-old child who accidentally shot his mother with an unsecured gun has pleaded not guilty to charges on Monday, according to KOMO News.

2 hours ago

Microsoft layoffs Redmond...

Jason Sutich

Microsoft confirms another round of layoffs at its Redmond campus

Microsoft has confirmed another round of layoffs at its Redmond campus, with 40 workers being laid off, as reported in a state filing.

3 hours ago

tacoma shooting...

Frank Lenzi

Tacoma police issue warning about scam calls

Tacoma police are warning residents about scam calls from people posing as law enforcement officers.

4 hours ago

‘Mamma Mia 2’ not nearly as terrible as the original